Scholarship Woes
Once the results of the SPM and STPM results are out, a lot of parents anbd students would be busy applying for scholarships. The excellent students would be applying diligently and with new e-applications, it is even easier. Thus the top-scorers would apply irrespective they are from the well-to-do or poor families. This creats a lot of problems for the PSD (Public Services Dept) or JPA in giving out the scholarships to the REALLY DESERVING students. And this year only 1500 scholarsips were given and the applicants amount to mote than 10,000.
Applications have been scrutinized strictly, according to the PSD. Awards are given to students who in addtion to performing well academically, must be active in their co-curicular activities plus excellent MUET results and commendable national services records. Yet on the day of announcements, a lot of resentments and disappointments are highlighted, not only in the webs but also in mainstream newspapers. This has become an annual affair. The students who get the scholarships are very happy. Yet,some would sulk a bit, saying , "I intend to do medicine in UK but given to do medicine in UM." . There is another who complained, "How come I got the scolarship to do Economics in Australia; but my schoolmate who got a distinction less was given to read Economics in London School of Econmics?"
The sad tales of course would be those who are unsuccessful. They screamed in front of the press that they have strings of A's yet they were deprived of the awards. "I would be happy if given to read Economics in UM, no need to do in UK." says one. Another one said, "I 'm not even asking to do medicine , just Psychology." One active student cried out, " I am the school head-boy, got straight A's, represnted the state in the game I excelled and have done the national services too. Yet I am left out." Sad tales are indeed plentiful.
The sadder tales were told in front of the press with the help of the politicians. This group sounds more deserving for the awards. "I am from the poor family. My dad is no longer with us and my mum supports the family by doing odd jobs in a restaurant." one student appealed. Another one mentioned, " I have straight A's and my dad is jobless due to the economic down-turn, have another 5 family members studying and right now I'm doing part-time job to supplement daily basic needs." The politicians were quick to say that they would finds ways to help this group and ease the parents' burdens in seeing the students proceed their tertiary educations. The politicians were certainly smiling and were sure to made some political mileage.
The saddest tales came from the "really, really" needy students. They are poor, diligent and have produced excellent results. Some were given, and as usual some were left out in the award list. One went to the press, " I am born a handicap and I have never swayed from my intention to get a good tertiary education. So I study hard to get straight A's . I want to study Economics with the PSD scholarship but was deprived just because I was in the Science stream." Another one said, " I am already handicap physically, and my family is merely taking a wage to see us through the day to on the day to day basis. Yet I am deprived and what is the point of doing well in the exams?" This group of students always finally get the attention of the PSD people, who will react positively after reading the news. Sometimes, some kind philanthropic-minded businessmen would come to their rescue and promise to see that these group of students achieve the tertairy educations.
Until now, actually noboby know how the PSD give out the scholarship awards. The criteria stated by the PSD is unclear and subjective. The interpretation of the terms is vague and only known to the selection panel members , who are given only two weeks to screen through more than 10,000 applicants and come out with the 1,500 successful names. Anyone who is in the panel must have wished that they would not be selected to be in the committee again. They are not thanked, yet being bombarded left and right by parents, press , bloggers, handicap people, non-government organisations, tax-payers and even students. Yet thay cannot say out their views and points to the press, becaust what they have done, is classified confidential..
Probably, the PSD should come out with a clearer guidelines to the application for the scholarship awrads. They could have stated that for the SPM holders, the applicants must have at least taken 15 papers and strike a minimum 13 As. That would reduce to a mere few hundreds applicants and sure these genuine applicants would 100% get it and be happy. Or applicants must have done the national services, then this is to make sure that PSD scholars are not NS shrickers. Or co-curricular activists must be ACTIVE at state level. At least with strict, tall orders l;ike these , the PSD may have only 500 applicants next year and there is no need to give out any rejection letters. Maybe the PSD would have to appeal for more students to apply. But I would suggest then that the PSD may give every successful applicant a year supply of the official breakfast, tea-break and supper "Teh 'Boh' Tarik" drink in addition to the scholarship.
